Two of the most popular cash back credit cards in Canada go head-to-head: both charge $120/year, both earn 4% at groceries and gas — but one has a major advantage for households with subscription bills.
Quick verdict: The Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite wins for most Canadians with automatic recurring bills — 4% on subscriptions, phone, internet, and insurance is a powerful differentiator. Choose CIBC Dividend if you’re a CIBC banking client or the recurring bills category is less relevant to your spending.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite | Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fee | $120 | $120 |
| Network | Visa Infinite | Visa Infinite |
| Income required | $60K personal / $100K household | $60K personal / $100K household |
| Earn — Grocery | 4% cash back | 4% cash back |
| Earn — Gas | 4% cash back | 4% cash back |
| Earn — Recurring bills | 2% cash back | 4% cash back |
| Earn — Dining | 2% cash back | 2% cash back |
| Earn — Everything else | 1% cash back | 1% cash back |
| Cash back redemption | Annual statement credit | Annual statement credit |
| Travel insurance | ✓ Comprehensive | ✓ Comprehensive |
| Foreign transaction fee | 2.5% | 2.5% |
| CIBC banking fee waiver | Sometimes available | N/A |
The Recurring Bills Difference
This is where the cards diverge:
What counts as recurring bills (Scotiabank Momentum):
- Cell phone / mobile plan
- Home internet service
- Streaming subscriptions (Netflix, Disney+, Apple TV+, Spotify, Amazon Prime)
- Home, auto, or life insurance premiums
- Gym memberships
- Other pre-authorized monthly charges
| Monthly Bills | CIBC Dividend (2%) | Scotia Momentum (4%) | Annual Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $200/month | $48/year | $96/year | +$48 |
| $300/month | $72/year | $144/year | +$72 |
| $400/month | $96/year | $192/year | +$96 |
| $500/month | $120/year | $240/year | +$120 |
On $400/month in recurring bills alone, the Scotiabank Momentum earns $96 more per year — nearly enough to cover the full annual fee.
Grocery and Gas: Equal
Both cards earn 4% cash back on groceries and gas — no difference here. This is the highest grocery cash back rate available on a standard (non-PC Optimum) credit card in Canada.
On $700/month grocery + $200/month gas ($10,800/year):
- Both cards earn: $432/year in cash back (at 4%)
Cash Back Calculation Example
Household spending: $700/month grocery, $200/month gas, $400/month recurring bills, $500/month other:
| Category | Monthly Spend | CIBC Dividend | Scotia Momentum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grocery | $700 | $336/year (4%) | $336/year (4%) |
| Gas | $200 | $96/year (4%) | $96/year (4%) |
| Recurring bills | $400 | $96/year (2%) | $192/year (4%) |
| Other | $500 | $60/year (1%) | $60/year (1%) |
| Total | $588/year | $684/year | |
| After $120 fee | $468 net | $564 net |
Scotia Momentum delivers $96 more per year in this scenario — increasing with more recurring bill spending.
Cash Back Redemption
Both cards pay cash back annually as a statement credit:
- CIBC Dividend: credited once per year (typically January for prior year)
- Scotiabank Momentum: credited once per year as a statement credit
Neither card offers on-demand or monthly redemption. If you want mid-year flexibility, consider a card like the Tangerine Money-Back (monthly cash back) or Rogers Red World Elite (monthly statement credit).
When to Choose CIBC Dividend
- You bank with CIBC and may qualify for an annual fee waiver
- You have minimal recurring automatic bills (subscriptions, insurance)
- You want CIBC ecosystem integration
- Your grocery and gas spending is very high but bills are low
When to Choose Scotiabank Momentum
- You have $200–$500/month in recurring pre-authorized bills
- You have a phone plan, internet, streaming subscriptions, and/or insurance on a card
- You don’t bank with CIBC (no fee waiver opportunity there)
- You want maximum cash back on all four categories: grocery, gas, recurring bills, and dining
Verdict
Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite wins for most households. The 4% on recurring bills is the decisive differentiator — most Canadians with a cell phone, internet, and even one streaming subscription clear $200/month in this category.
CIBC Dividend is preferred for CIBC banking clients who may receive an annual fee waiver, making the effective annual fee $0 — at which point the 2% vs 4% recurring bills gap matters less.
Related Articles
- CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite Review 2026
- Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite Review 2026
- Best Cash Back Credit Cards in Canada 2026
- Best Grocery Credit Cards in Canada 2026
- Best Gas Credit Cards in Canada 2026
Card details current as of June 2026. Cash back earn rates and redemption terms subject to change. Verify with the issuer before applying. See our Advertiser Disclosure.